I Taste Tested 9 Keto Tortillas to Find the Best One for You!

With so many keto tortillas now available in stores and online, it’s hard to know which is best. 

Have you seen the keto tortilla aisle lately?

I don’t know about you, but since starting keto, I have typically avoided the bread and tortilla aisles. That is until now! There are so many different tortilla options available, both non-keto and keto — it’s crazy! Like almost an entire aisle devoted to tortillas. It could just be my area, but I’m curious if it’s the same where you live?

To determine the best keto tortilla, I grabbed every low-carb, keto tortilla I could find at my local Kroger store. I found seven options in store, even a Kroger brand low-carb tortilla. I also ordered the most popular keto tortillas off Amazon, the Mr. Tortilla keto tortillas. And then a few weeks after I did my taste test, Hero Bread sent me their tortillas to try, and I do think they deserve a mention as well.

Which is the best keto tortilla?

To start off, I need to do a disclaimer. The majority of keto tortillas fall into the “dirty keto” category. I wish they didn’t but they do! For the most part, they have a long list of ingredients and add a lot of fiber to make the “net carbs” as low as possible.

There are some cleaner almond flour tortillas available, like Siete, but they add tapioca flour which significantly brings up the carb count. Your best option is really to make your own keto tortillas, but the convenience factor of buying premade ones is hard to pass up.

We have recipes for keto hard taco shells, our keto-dilla, and jicama wraps are always an option, too. I might even need to try my hand at my own recipe for homemade keto tortillas next time the craving hits!

Now onto the keto tortilla taste test…

To fully test out these tortillas, I tried all of them plain, straight out of the package. I then made a basic cheese quesadilla with each brand of tortilla to really see how they held up. I tried my best to make all of the quesadillas at once to accurately compare them but it took me two batches.

So here are the results!

---

LaTortilla Factory – 3g Net Carbs

I’ll start by saying I really wanted to like these tortillas. They do a pretty good job of using clean ingredients like expeller-pressed canola oil. Even though I know what all the ingredients are, the texture just wasn’t right for me. I found them to be really chewy straight from the package and they were still chewy when cooked in the quesadilla. They also tasted bland, like they needed salt.

Overall Rating: 4/10

---

La Banderita Carb Counter – 4g Net Carbs

These keto tortillas tasted doughy to me. I didn’t really like the texture of them fresh and found that they got pretty stiff when I cooked them in a quesadilla. They were also bland tasting. Overall, these were my least favorite.

Overall Rating: 3/10

---

Guerrero Nutri-Ricas Carb Watch Flour Tortillas – 4g Net Carbs

These keto tortillas weren’t too bad. I liked them much better cooked than plain. The overall texture was still a little too chewy and they tasted bland to me. I also don’t like that they have sucralose in them. I don’t think tortillas need to be sweetened. 🤔

Overall Rating: 4/10

---

Don Pancho Carb Control Wraps – 3g Net Carbs

I didn’t mind these keto tortillas. If I hadn’t been comparing them to all the other keto tortillas, I don’t think I would’ve had any issues with them. This is a tortilla that tasted much better cooked. I found it dry on its own but when in a cheese quesadilla, it crisped up nicely and tasted pretty good! The downside is in the ingredients – vegetable oil shortening and sucralose.

Overall Rating: 5/10

---

Olé Xtreme Wellness High Fiber Carb Lean – 4g Net Carbs

These keto tortillas are pretty good! I’ve used them before in keto recipes and liked them. They are very soft and a little chewy. They taste a little bland by themselves but are good once used in a recipe.

Overall Rating: 6/10

---

Kroger Low Carb Flour Tortillas – 6g Net Carbs

I was surprised by these keto tortillas. The texture and flavor were shockingly good. The downside is that they have 6g of net carbs. These ones are a little higher on the carb count than the other tortillas I tested. When I tried these plain, I found them to be a little chewy. But they cooked up really nice and ended up with a pleasing flakey texture. The other downside is sucralose listed in the ingredients.

Overall Rating: 7/10

---

Mr. Tortilla – 1g Net Carb

These cute little keto tortillas are actually really good! ☺️ They only have 1g net carb per tortilla but note that they are street taco-sized tortillas. They do make bigger tortillas, but I just happened to get these on Amazon as they are the #1 best seller for keto tortillas. Another win for these tortillas is that they’re made with avocado oil, which is great for keto!

Overall Rating: 8/10

---

Mission Carb Balance Soft Taco Flour Tortillas – 4g Net Carbs

These were originally my favorite from the taste test (before I got the final tortilla I mention next). Honestly, it surprised me that I liked these the best because in the past I have not been a fan of Mission Tortillas. But these have a really good flavor and texture. They also held up great when I made the quesadilla. When cooked, they had the perfect flakey texture that I want in a tortilla.

The negative with these is that they have a small amount of sucralose.

Overall Rating: 9/10

---

Hero Bread Tortillas – 0g Net Carbs

I received these after I did the taste test with all of the other keto tortillas. They’re so good that you can read my full product review here! I’ve made a lot of quesadillas and breakfast burritos with Hero’s tortillas and had no complaints. I even fed them to some friends and no one asked if they were keto, so that’s a score in my book!

The only bummer about these is that you have to buy them online and they are a bit more expensive than the ones you can find in the grocery store.

Overall Rating: 9/10

---

Check out some of our amazing recipes that use keto tortillas:

• Breakfast Burrito Hack
• Keto Crunchwrap Supreme
• Keto Tortilla Roll-Ups with Every Bagel Seasoning
• Make-Ahead Keto Breakfast Burritos
• Low-Carb Chimichangas

---

Do you have a favorite keto tortilla or have you tried the ones in this post? If so, let us know what you think in the comments!

---

If you liked this taste test, check out my keto sweetener taste test with keto sugar cookies!