Would You Pay $24.99 For a Box of Keto Pop-Tarts?

Hip2Keto may earn a small commission via affiliate links in this post. Read our full disclosure policy here.

More Deals

man holding Legendary Foods Tasty Pastry

You can now buy keto-fied Pop-Tarts! 🙌

If you’re tired of eating eggs for breakfast and want a yummy keto pastry, then we have just the thing for you, but keep in mind that it’ll cost ya – $24.99 for a 10-count box to be exact (well, actually a bit less with our exclusive promo code listed at the bottom of this post).

Recently, we tried the new Legendary Foods Low-Carb Tasty Pastry

wooman eating legendary pastry

The Legendary Foods Tasty Pastry is available in two flavors – brown sugar and strawberry!

keto strawberry toaster pastry on plate

Say hello to this quick and easy breakfast or snack idea! 👋

Tasty Pastry strawberry variety sitting on counter

Tasty Pastry Strawberry

Nutrition: Serving Size 1 Pastry | 170 Calories | 13g Fat | 21g Total Carbs | 8g Dietary Fiber | 5g Erythritol | 4g Allulose | 4g Net Carbs | 9g Protein

legendary foods cinnamon pastry

Tasty Pastry Brown Sugar Cinnamon

Nutrition: Serving Size 1 Pastry | 170 Calories | 13g Fat | 21g Total Carbs | 8g Dietary Fiber | 6g Erythritol | 4g Allulose | 3g Net Carbs | 9g Protein

Legendary Foods tasty pastry nutrition

We realize that many consider these pastries to be dirty keto, so please keep that in mind when deciding if they are something you want to add to your meal or snack options.

Here’s what Legendary Foods has to say about their Tasty Pastry products:

“You have no idea how complicated this was.

To make a product that you ate during your childhood without the very thing that they were made of – carbs and sugar. To keep all the wholesome feelings and delectable taste while eliminating the blood sugar spike and making our version out of real FOOD that supports your nutrition goals.

Crazy, we know.

But like you, we missed eating toaster pastries. And Saturday morning cartoons.

So we got to work in the kitchen. For years. Our first attempts were so disappointing we second guessed ourselves. It might not be possible. After all, it was like saying we wanted to make an igloo without snow or ice. Hell, toaster pastries ARE carbs and sugar.

But it’s amazing what thousands of experiments, talking to experts and sticking doggedly to a burning vision can do.

We finally succeeded. Where once lay gobs of diabetes inducing carbohydrate and sugar now stood a chiseled form made of protein, fat and fiber.

And oh the taste.

Tasty Pastries have been back in our lives for months now. And now they can be in yours.”

On the fence? Here’s what Collin & Stetson think of Legendary Foods Tasty Pastry treats…

woman holding out keto toaster pastry and coffee mug

“Keto Pop-Tarts?! YES! This is such a fun treat to have on occasion. I thought these were good – however, keep in mind that they don’t taste like a typical high-carb Pop-Tart, but they are still yummy for being so low in carbs. I think they taste the best when you put them in the microwave or toaster for a few seconds. My favorite flavor is the cinnamon!” 😋 Collin

man holding keto cinnamon toaster pastry

“If you’re doing keto and have a sweet tooth, you’ll want to give these pastries a try! Although you can definitely tell a difference between a regular Pop-Tart vs. the Legendary Foods Tasty Pastry, they still taste surprisingly good, especially for being a low carb item. I like that it isn’t overbearing in sweetness and doesn’t have a weird aftertaste like so many keto products do.” Stetson

Ready to try them for yourself?

We have an exclusive discount just for you! Head over to Legendary Foods and use promo code HIP2KETO at checkout to save an additional 10% off your purchase! 

woman holding Legendary Foods keto pop-tart with box on counter

Tasty Pastry 10-Pack $24.99
Use promo code HIP2KETO (save 10%)
Final cost $22.50 for all 10 –  $2.25 each!

Here are 10 of the Best Keto Desserts to Buy!

Angela graduated with a Bachelor's Degree and has 20+ years of experience as a writer and photographer with her work being featured in US Weekly Magazine, The Los Angeles Times, People Magazine, and more.

Join The Discussion

Comments 15

  1. Trbobitch

    No. And definitely NOT with the terrible, non-food product, artificial ingredients list.

  2. Scarlet B

    Nope. I don’t even like actual poptarts.

  3. falene


  4. Marion

    No way, make your own

  5. Tammie Johnson

    Yes. I would at least try them once and if I didn’t care for them I wouldn’t have to buy them anymore. I miss being able to eat the high carb pop tarts so Thanks for coming up with these.

    • Angie (Hip2Keto Sidekick)

      Hi Tammie! Let us know what you think. We thought they were a fun product❤

      • Tammie Johnson

        Hello Angie
        I will let you know. Thanks so much.

  6. Patti

    The price is ridiculous.

  7. Tawna Young

    oh my gosh!! I have been dying for a poptart!!!! I would buy them for sure. Are they available in any stores?

    • Jennifer (Hip Sidekick)

      Not yet! You can order them online.

  8. Carol

    No way!

  9. Sal Collaziano

    They’re so good, I bought 5 boxes.

    • Jennifer (Hip Sidekick)


  10. Fran Katz

    Yes, I purchased them. When I saw the back of the strawberry one, it was damp and strawberry coming through, so I baked it and it’s not worth it. Did I feel full? Yes. Was it anything like I remembered? No way! We’ve tried 2 of the ten and truth… they aren’t good. I purchased on amazon. I checked freshness date. 7 of 2021, so they are fresh but not fabulous. I wish I had tried the brown sugar cinnamon. Alas, I will pass.

    • Angie (Hip2Keto Sidekick)

      Hi Fran! That’s a bummer! So sorry you didn’t love them. 💔

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

OOPS! Be sure to login or register to access this feature. It's FREE!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a comment?